DISTRICTSCORE.com
Sign inGet Pro
Neighborhood

Montclair Colony

New York US
AI SummaryUpdated May 2026
Area
28.73 mi²
ZIP Code
11964
County
Suffolk County
State
New York
Redfin — median sale & volumeFEMA National Risk Index v1.20OpenStreetMap — POIFBI UCR — state crimeEPA — radon zonesEPA FRS / BTS — hazard screeningUS Census ACS / TIGER 2024
Verified Price · Median Sale
$3,236,539
YoY
Gross Rental Yield
Listed rent · ZORI annualized
Red Flag Index
High
73 / 100
Walkability Score
35
Car-Dependent
OpenStreetMap POI density · national percentile
Education Score
82 / 100
Excellent · better than 82% of U.S. districts
Pre-pandemic SEDA (2018/19) · district proxy
AI Score
20
Limited
DistrictScore attractiveness · national model

Montclair Colony Property Prices & Rental Yield

Verified Redfin sale data and Zillow ZORI asking rent.

Unlock the Montclair Colony 12-month price trend
See the full Verified vs Listed price history — free with a DistrictScore account.
Sign in to view — free
Market Economics Snapshot
May 2026
MetricValueYoY
Median Sale Price$3,236,539
Price / Sq Ft (Verified)$781/sqft-36.3%
Liquidity Score6 / 100Low
Homes Sold (Period)4+300.0%

Is Montclair Colony Safe? Natural-Hazard Risk

FEMA National Risk Index composite across eight hazards, plus inherited New York crime context.

Unlock the Montclair Colony hazard breakdown
See all eight FEMA hazard scores — free with a DistrictScore account.
Sign in to view — free
What Stands Out AI Insight
Flood risk is Very High (100/100)
Hurricane risk is Very High (100/100)
Insights are generated from Montclair Colony's live DistrictScore metrics.

Montclair Colony Environment & Safety

Satellite PM2.5 air-quality history, FBI UCR crime trend (New York-level, the finest official aggregation), EPA radon potential and point-source hazard screening.

New York Crime Trend
FBI UCR
20132024
All crimes / 1k
Violent / 1k
YearCrimes / 1kViolent / 1kYoY
202421.03.8-3.7%
202321.93.9+2.4%
202221.54.3+57.0%
202113.63.1-21.5%
202017.73.6+0.9%
201917.53.6
Reported at the state level — the finest official US crime aggregation; Montclair Colony inherits the New York figures.
Radon Potential
EPA
Zone 3
Zone 3 — Lowest potential · Montclair Colony
EPA radon zones estimate indoor radon potential county-wide (Zone 1 highest, Zone 3 lowest). Testing is recommended in all zones.
Environmental Hazards
EPA / BTS
Superfund (NPL)3.9 kmModerate
Point-source screening near Montclair Colony: EPA Superfund National Priorities List & Facility Registry (2026), BTS aviation noise (2020, 24-hour average level). Superfund shows distance to the nearest listed site; odor shows detected sources within the screening radius. Only detected sources are listed; the bar shows severity vs. all U.S. neighborhoods.

Walkability & Amenities in Montclair Colony

Amenity density and pedestrian access from OpenStreetMap points of interest.

Walkability & Amenities
OpenStreetMap POI
35
Car-Dependent
Walkability Score
4
Grocery
9
Dining
2
Schools
0
Universities
1
Hospitals
0
Pharmacies
2
Parks
4
Rail Transit
0
Coworking
POI counts are amenities within Montclair Colony's boundary plus a 400 m walk buffer. Rail transit excludes bus stops.

Montclair Colony vs City vs New York

How Montclair Colony benchmarks against its city and state medians.

Unlock the Montclair Colony benchmark
Compare Montclair Colony against its city and New York medians — free with a DistrictScore account.
Sign in to view — free

Buying Property in the US as a Foreigner

Federal & New York tax facts for non-resident buyers, plus the latest local market news.

Buying as a Foreigner
US Tax & Ownership
Applies to everyone7
Capital Gains (Federal)
Long-term capital gains taxed federally at 0/15/20%, plus a 3.8% Net Investment Income Tax on higher incomes (2026).
Property Tax
Property tax: ~1.23% average effective rate (statewide average; set and collected locally).
State Income Tax
State income tax up to 10.9%; rental income is taxed at these rates.
State Capital Gains
Capital gains are taxed as ordinary income at state rates.
Transfer Tax
Real estate transfer tax: 0.4% state + NYC tax; mansion tax 1%+ (NYC to 3.9%).
Assessment Cap
NYC limits assessment growth on small homes; the assessment does not reset on sale.
Mansion Tax / Rent Control
Mansion tax runs from 1% ($1M) up to 3.9% (NYC, $25M+); New York City has rent stabilization.
US citizens & tax residents7
Primary-Home Exclusion
Selling your main home: exclude up to $250k of gain (single) / $500k (married) if you owned and lived there 2 of the last 5 years.
1031 Like-Kind Exchange
A 1031 like-kind exchange defers capital gains tax on investment property; 45 days to identify, 180 to close. Real estate only.
Depreciation Recapture
Residential rentals depreciate over 27.5 years; on sale, recaptured depreciation is taxed up to 25% (Section 1250).
Mortgage Interest Deduction
Mortgage interest is deductible on up to $750k of home debt. The SALT cap rose to $40,000 for 2025-2029 (reverts to $10k in 2030).
Opportunity Zones
Opportunity Zones are now permanent (2025): reinvested capital gains get deferral plus a basis step-up, and are tax-free after 10 years.
Rental Income (Resident)
Rental income is reported on Schedule E; passive-loss rules (Section 469) limit deducting rental losses against other income.
1031 State Conformity
The state conforms to the federal 1031 like-kind exchange rules.
Foreign buyers (non-residents)5
FIRPTA (Foreign Sellers)
FIRPTA: the buyer withholds 15% of the gross sale price when a nonresident sells US property. It is an advance deposit, not the final tax.
Non-Resident Capital Gains
Nonresident sellers pay US capital gains tax (generally 15-20%) on the net gain via Form 1040-NR; FIRPTA withholding is credited.
Non-Resident Rental Tax
Nonresident rental income is taxed at 30% of gross by default, or on net income at graduated rates via a Section 871(d) election (W-8ECI).
Estate Tax (Non-Resident)
Nonresidents get only a $60,000 US estate-tax exemption (vs $13.99M for residents); US property above it is taxed up to 40%. Treaties may help.
ITIN Requirement
Nonresidents without an SSN need an ITIN (Form W-7) to file US tax returns, claim FIRPTA refunds, and report rental income.
Talk to a US real-estate tax advisor
FIRPTA, ITIN & New York property-tax guidance for foreign buyers
Unlock deeper insights on Montclair Colony
Deeper data. Smarter decisions. Stronger returns.
Full Risk Reports
Tract-level hazards
Investment Score
AI-driven analysis
Export & Reports
PDF & Excel
Priority Support
Fast-track help
Get Pro Access7-day free trial. Cancel anytime.